The Fat Lady Sings
March 24, 2010 - 4:13 AMHealth care is not a right. The enormously fat -- and proud of it -- Donna Simpson doesn't have a right to force me to pay for her health care any more than I have a right to force her to pay for my electricity.
There’s a reason that Obama, Biden, Pelosi and Reid don’t use Simpson as one of their typical sob stories: Simpson weighs 604 pounds, and she’s trying to work her way up to 1,000 pounds so that she can make the “Guinness Book of World Records.” “This is a fantasy of mine,” Simpson told the New York Post. According to the Post, Simpson would love to hit 1,000 pounds by 2012, consuming a diet of 12,000 calories per day.
“My favorite food is sushi,” she told the UK’s Daily Mail, “but unlike others I can sit and eat 70 big pieces of sushi in one go. I do love cakes and sweet things, doughnuts are my favorite.”
How does she pay $750 per week for her food? She has a website where people can donate money to watch the hog feed herself. “I love eating and people love watching me eat. It makes people happy, and I’m not harming anyone.”
Well, that used to be true. She wasn’t harming anyone because we weren’t paying for her (or, at least, we weren’t paying for her unless she had a heart attack and ended up in the emergency room). Now we are paying for her. All of us. We’re paying for her because insurance companies in America are no longer allowed to charge her higher premiums due to her pre-existing medical condition (i.e. being a load). They’re no longer allowed to provide her coverage limits (i.e. limits on bypasses), and they’re no longer allowed to tailor a policy for her that leaves out preventive care (care she’ll never use since her goal is to be two Michael Moores).
If Simpson is smart (granted, a big if), she’ll simply pay a $750 fine and avoid buying health insurance. Then when she gets sick due to her grain-elevator size, she’ll sign up for health insurance. The money she pays per year won’t come close to covering her care. That means we’ll cover it.
If this sounds like a bad idea, that’s because it is. It’s a horrible, terrible, anti-American idea. And it stems from the similarly awful idea that health care is a right. Once health care is defined as an individual right, society suddenly has an obligation to provide it. And society is made up of other individuals, who will have to come out of pocket to pay for the irresponsible.
In fact, health care is not a right. Donna Simpson doesn’t have a right to force me to pay for her health care any more than I have a right to force her to pay for my electricity.
Having the opportunity to control your health (and your health care) is a right, however. Or at least, it was a right.
Over the past few decades, health care in this country has moved from a patient-centric system to a government and insurance company-centric system. That’s due solely to government regulation—when medical care isn’t regulated, the price drops and the quality increases (just look at Lasik surgery, which generally isn’t covered by government programs or by health insurance programs). Free markets ensure rights, because rights are all about choice.
But the left doesn’t believe in true rights or true choice. True rights come with the responsibility to live with the consequences of your choices. The right to control your health comes with the responsibility to live with your choices. Donna Simpson has every right to turn herself into a human hippopotamus, but that action has certain consequences—namely, that she will pay for her own medical care.
The minute those consequences disappear, the right itself disappears, because rights without responsibilities are utterly unsustainable. It is only a matter of time before the government forces those like Donna Simpson to go on a Federal Diet Plan in order to “bend the cost curve,” forcing the rest of us to get on the Government Health Control bandwagon.
The left burned down the village in order to save it; they destroyed our control of our own health in order to guarantee health coverage for everyone. Our dearest freedom is now in the hands of the collective—all to save Donna Simpson.