Pelosi Says 'Are You Serious?' When Asked Constitutional Basis for Health Insurance Mandate
Thursday, October 22, 2009 EST


When House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D.-Calif.) was asked where Constitution gives Congress authority to mandate that every American buy health insurance, she responded: "Are you serious?"
Viewer Comments
The following comments are posted by our readers and are not necessarily the opinions of either CNSNews.com or the story’s author. To be considered for publication, comments must adhere to the Terms of Use for posting to this Web site. Thank you.

Showing 1-4 of 4
  Comments
 
BuzWeston (10 days ago)     

@jsamans, Your comment doesn't address the question. Congress may only do those things specifically allowed by the Constitution. This isn't an argument about which unconstitutional things other people might like. That's a red herring. Also, you are relying on the two wrongs make a right fallacy. The last time I checked the United States of America is still a government of laws and not of men. (In case you're an illiterate liberal, "men" means humans).

jsamans (11 days ago)     

If you can take a moment to stop spouting your sound bites from the latest Glenn Beck airing, might you explain why you think it would be unconstitutional for the U.S. government to mandate health insurance? Before you respond, you might be interested to know that the basis for the Partial Birth Abortion Ban Act was the Commerce Clause of the Constitution. Count to thirty as you think that through, then explain to me why you imagine that mandating health insurance is beyond the powers of the Constitution.

fanofthegreatone (22 days ago)     

IMO, this should be our #1 priority – to fight back and defeat any national health care bills. Hopefully the GOP will get its act together (getting back to conservative principles) and we can win back the White House and Congress by 2012. In that case, we can easily cut taxes, roll back much of the trillions of BHO’s profligate spending, sell GM and banks back to the private sector, and reverse a lot of the damage caused by BHO. But if ‘National Hell Care’ passes – once in effect it will be very hard to reverse. Just look at England. Tea parties are great – i.e., using tea bag boxes and “Taxed Enough Already” signs as symbols. What we really need now are anti-NHC rallies, such as we saw in the 1990s against ‘Hillary-Care’. As I remember a scene from Rush Limbaugh’s TV show, I can think of great symbols to use in rallies against NHC – bathroom tissue rolls attached to signs saying something like: “Here’s Pelosi’s/Reid’s 1000+ page bills”!!

mr.nice (24 days ago)     

ImpeachBarackObama.com. HIS MIDDLE NAME AND HIS CZARS SAYS IT ALL =ALLAH ALLAH. NOT HERE SEND THEM ALL BACK TO HE!! REMEMBER ONE THING THE CZARS ARE NOW THE POWER (NOT) THE ELECTED ONES THEY ARE JUST THE FACE OF THE DECEPTION NEED I SAY BARNEY FRANK!!!


Post New Comment
You must be logged in to leave comments! Click here to log in.


Free CNSNews.com Daily E-Brief
Enter your e-mail to start receiving daily CNSNews.com stories in your inbox!


Video Infomation

Embed Code:

(customize)

Video URL:


CNSNews.com Toolbox
  •                 click above!
  • Subscribe to CNSNews.com
  • CNSNews.com News Ticker