Court dogs provide calm for traumatized witnesses
POUGHKEEPSIE, N.Y. (AP) — A 15-year-old girl had special help when she took the witness stand Monday at the trial for the man accused of sexually assaulting her for four years.
Rose, an 11-year-old golden retriever whose regular job is helping provide therapy in schools for troubled children, was there at her side, helping to calm a child who experts said is otherwise incapable of talking about her traumatic ordeal.
It's an unprecedented arrangement in New York and now gaining acceptance elsewhere. Pioneered by a Seattle prosecutor in 2003, courthouse dogs are participating in trials in at least 10 states, often over the objections of defense lawyers who worry that the dogs generate extra sympathy for victims and witnesses.
During a little more than an hour on the stand, Rose was mostly invisible Monday. When the girl was asked to point out the man who is charged with raping her for four years starting at the age of 10, the dog poked her muzzle up and the girl stroked it. When she was asked to go into graphic detail about the rapes, she looked down and patted the dog.
Dutchess County Judge Stephen Greller had rejected a defense argument that Rose's presence might prejudice the jury. Greller said he relied in part on an earlier New York case involving a "comfort item," a teddy bear held by a child witness in an early 1990s sex-crime trial.
Before the girl and jurors were brought in, a handler led Rose to the witness box, where she was placed mostly out of view under the supervision of the judge. When jurors returned, Greller introduced the witness and told the panel she was with a companion animal, but that they shouldn't draw any conclusion from that or allow sympathy to sway them.
The girl gave mostly short answers, steadily reaching down with one hand on the lead and one hand on Rose. The jury of seven women and five men gave no indication they even noticed the dog.
The girl, dressed in a dark top and pants, her dark hair in braids, pursed or bit her lips as she responded to questions, nervously draining a small white cup of water while cross-examination began. At one point, under questioning from the defense lawyer, she took a deep breath, looked down and appeared to whisper to Rose.
Ellen O'Neill-Stephens, a prosecutor in Seattle who founded the organization Courthouse Dogs, has championed dogs helping witnesses. She said they are "an incredible tool" for helping calm victims "reliving the trauma as they're describing what happened to them."
Their use gained traction after a 2004 U.S. Supreme Court ruling on a defendant's right to confront an accuser threw into doubt the legality of allowing victims to testify remotely by two-way video or other means to avoid the stressful environment of the courtroom.
"Now you had kids right up there in the face of the person who did this to them," O'Neill-Stephens said.
"We had an occasion in our courthouse where a child just froze," she said, describing a witness scared by the presence of a defendant's relatives. "All it took was playing with the dog to tell the judge he was afraid of them."
The relatives were ordered out of court.
O'Neill-Stephens lists 18 jurisdictions in Washington, Idaho, California, Texas, Missouri, Arizona, Pennsylvania, Hawaii and New Mexico with courthouse dog programs.
Rose was trained by Dale Picard, founder of Educated Canines Assisting with Disabilities. The animal works in the organization's vocational education program at six alternative schools near New York City for children with emotional, behavioral and learning problems.
The animal is trained to work with victims of post-traumatic stress disorder, traumatized and special needs children, veterans at VA hospitals and others. She has been trained to sense anxiety and to try to reduce stress by nuzzling a person or seeking to be petted.
Studies show that such interactions have a strong calming effect, including lowering blood pressure, said David Crenshaw, a clinical psychologist at the facility where the girl is living.
Before the girl took the stand, defense lawyer David Martin repeated his objections.
Martin, the public defender representing 36-year-old Victor Tohom, has objected not only to the potential that Rose would generate prejudicial empathy among jurors, but the fact there is no law in New York allowing the dog to accompany her. He said Greller's decision allowing the dog will be part of any appeal if Tohom is convicted on the charge of predatory sexual assault against a child.
Greller asked Martin to suggest special instructions he should give jurors before they deliberate, something O'Neill-Stephens said is vital to avoiding issues on appeal.
Senior Assistant District Attorney Kristine Hawlk, the prosecutor who filed the motion to allow Rosie in court, said she couldn't discuss the case.
To date, there has been no case law from an appeals court on the practice, O'Neill-Stephens said, but "some defense attorneys successfully object to the presence of the dog and the judge doesn't want to go out on a limb."
She said defense lawyers in her jurisdiction have generally stopped objecting. Some even use the dogs to advantage, petting them as they cross-examine a witness, perhaps softening jurors' views of them as interrogators.
"The dogs are for everybody in the criminal justice system," O'Neill-Stephens said.