Commentary

Virginia May Release Many Inmates Guilty of Involuntary Manslaughter or Other Crimes

By Hans Bader | August 17, 2020 | 12:36pm EDT
Prisoners stand behind bars. (Photo credit: Giles Clarke/Contributor/Getty Images)
Prisoners stand behind bars. (Photo credit: Giles Clarke/Contributor/Getty Images)

Virginia's legislature has a good chance of releasing many prison inmates guilty of involuntary manslaughter.

In its special session this August, legislators plan to pass Senate Bill 5034, which would shorten many inmates' sentences by increasing the number of credits most inmates receive for good behavior while in prison. The bill would not apply to people who commit rape or murder, but it would benefit inmates who committed many other serious offenses. Such offenses include not just involuntary manslaughter, but also other crimes, such as drunk driving, home invasions, or violent assaults that injured people but were not intended to kill or maim.

It would apply even to inmates whose crimes are part of a long pattern of criminal activity. So career criminals could be released -- like the habitual drunk driver who kills someone after driving drunk many times, or the career thief who steals millions of dollars.

Right now, prison inmates in Virginia who avoid major misbehavior receive good-behavior credits. The credits give them a 4.5-day reduction in their sentence for every 30 days in which they behave. For the majority of Virginia inmates, Senate Bill 5034 would increase that reduction. For many, that reduction would eventually rise to "one day for each one day served" -- nearly seven times the current rate. (In the first year of such good behavior, they would receive up to 13 days reduction in their sentence for every 30 days served, triple the current reduction; in the second year of such good behavior, they would receive up to 16 days off for every 30 days served; in the third year, up to 20 days off; in the fourth year, up to 25 days off; and in the fifth and any consecutive year thereafter, they would get up to a full day off their sentence for each day served.)

Shortening criminals' sentences will increase crime rates. The National Bureau of Economic Research notes that longer sentences "reduce crime," citing research in the Journal of Law & Economics.

Forty years ago, Virginia’s Fairfax County had a similar crime rate to Montgomery County, Md., because they are demographically and economically similar. But that changed, after prison sentences became longer in Virginia, and Virginia eliminated parole. Fairfax County ended up with a much lower crime rate than Montgomery County.

ABC7 discussed this in 2019 in a piece called "Why Is Montgomery County's Violent Crime Rate Twice As High As Neighboring Fairfax County?" Law enforcement sources attributed Montgomery's higher crime rate to the fact "that the Maryland Judiciary is, generally speaking, more lenient on criminal defendants" and the fact that "Virginia has stricter laws on the books" and "harsh sentences," which are "a huge deterrent" to crime. "Criminals know if you commit crime in Virginia you might get whacked, while in Maryland, you might just get slapped on the wrist."

Senate Bill 5034 has a good chance of passage, because it currently has 9 co-sponsors in Virginia's state senate, and appears to have the backing of most Democrats in the Virginia Senate.

Releasing career criminals early is harmful to our society and our economy. If not kept in prison, a career criminal can inflict hundreds of thousands of dollars of economic harm, annually, far more than the cost of jailing that criminal. A 1998 study in the Journal of Quantitative Criminology estimated that there were “$165,000 in victim costs per year of a criminal’s career” for a typical “career criminal,” including “lost wages and medical bills” and “lost quality of life to victims."

Of course, not all crimes have victims. Some people are in state prisons for victimless crimes, such as drug possession. The sentence reductions in Senate Bill 5034 would make sense for drug offenders, whose sentences are already plenty long enough. But most prison inmates aren't in there for drugs. In 2017, the Bureau of Justice Statistics found that over 55 percent of state prison inmates in America were there for “violent offenses,” and only 15 percent for drug crimes (such as drug dealing and manufacturing). And most people in prison for drug crimes are not there just for using drugs: As the progressive Marshall Project noted in 2015, “only 4 percent” of state prison inmates “are there for drug possession. An additional 12 percent are incarcerated for drug sales, manufacturing, or trafficking.”

Senate Bill 5034 should be revised to exclude more serious crimes from its sentence reductions, such as those who commit involuntary manslaughter or steal millions of dollars, or repeat offenders who assault others, drive drunk, or commit home invasions or other serious burglaries. Right now, if a crime does not qualify as a specified "act of violence" under Virginia Code § 19.2-297.1, or a specified "felony offense in Article 4" of Title 18.2, Chapter 8, the offender is eligible for a shorter sentence under Senate Bill 5034, regardless of how repeatedly the criminal violated the law, or how much harm the offender inflicted.

It makes sense to give inmates good-behavior sentence credits as an incentive to behave in prison. But Virginia law's current 4.5-day reduction for 30 days of good behavior is already enough incentive to behave. Senate Bill 5034 would increase that reduction by a huge amount that is far more than what's needed to provide an incentive to behave -- up to 30 days off for every 30 days they behave after five years.

Such huge reductions are really a form of parole, not a mere incentive for good behavior. Virginia largely abolished parole in 1995, because it was unpopular and unwise to let criminals out of prison when they had not served most of their sentence.

(There is also legislation pending in Virginia to reinstate parole. But that legislation, SB 5016, will probably not pass in this special session of the legislature. It does not yet appear to have the support of the full Democratic caucus, and Virginia's state senate is split 21-to-19 in favor of Democrats, meaning almost all Democrats must support a bill for it to pass. That legislation would allow even murderers and rapists to be paroled, with most premeditated murderers being eligible for parole after 15 years. I discussed the pitfalls of that legislation here and here.)

Hans Bader practices law in Washington, D.C. After studying economics and history at the University of Virginia and law at Harvard, he practiced civil-rights, international-trade, and constitutional law. He also once worked in the Education Department.

CNSNews Reader,

The media are hard at work weaving a web of confusion, misinformation, and conspiracy surrounding the COVID-19 pandemic.

CNSNews covers the stories that the liberal media are afraid to touch. It drives the national debate through real, honest journalism—not by misrepresenting or ignoring the facts.

CNSNews has emerged as the conservative media’s lynchpin for original reporting, investigative reporting, and breaking news. We are part of the only organization purely dedicated to this critical mission and we need your help to fuel this fight.

Donate today to help CNSNews continue to report on topics that the liberal media refuse to touch. $25 a month goes a long way in the fight for a free and fair media.

And now, thanks to the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act, you can make up to a $300 gift to the 501(c)(3) non-profit organization of your choice and use it as a tax deduction on your 2020 taxes, even if you take the standard deduction on your returns.

— The CNSNews Team

DONATE

Connect

Sign up for our CNSNews Daily Newsletter to receive the latest news.